Looks like I need to learn to read:
http://docs.splunk.com/Documentation/Splunk/6.6.0/Installation/Aboutupgradingto6.6READTHISFIRST
Connectivity over SSL between version 6.6 and versions less than 5.0 is disabled by default
Because of changes to the security ciphers in version 6.6 of Splunk Enterprise, instances of Splunk software that run on version 5.0 or less cannot connect to instances of version 6.6 or greater by default.
When you upgrade, any instances that run version 5.0 or less will no longer communicate with the upgraded instance over SSL. To work around the problem, edit inputs.conf and outputs.conf on the sending instances to enable ciphers that allow communication between the instances.
... View more