Thanks on the even/oddness of members. In terms of what Splunk advises, I don't see any mention of having an odd number of members: https://docs.splunk.com/Documentation/Splunk/8.0.4/DistSearch/SHCarchitecture We have two main SHC, one with 5 heads and one with 6 heads. We haven't seen many of the election issues you mention that I am aware of. I have also administered a SHC with 4, again without issues. We have occasionally seen times where a head will decide that another member is more worthy to be captain, presumably based on some kind of timing issues. Never quite sure. We live with 6 heads and have hundreds of users.
... View more