Deployment Architecture

Can volume definitions point to a unique path per indexer in an indexer cluster?

rvdv
Explorer

Hi, 

I have a question related to defining volumes especially the coldvolume in our case. 
I want to point the coldvolume to a unique location on network attached storage. 

Example we have 3 indexers with the following hostnames
idx01
idx02
idx03

say we have a local mount point on every indexer which points to the NAS mynas

/mnt/coldvolume -> nfs://mynas

Option 1
Can I then define a volume in /etc/system/local/indexes.conf on every indexer. 

On idx01:
[volume:coldvolume]
path = /mnt/coldvolume/idx01/

On idx02
[volume:coldvolume]
path = /mnt/coldvolume/idx02/

On idx03
[volume:coldvolume]
path = /mnt/coldvolume/idx03/

The indexes that are then distributed to all indexers in this cluster are of the format 
[myniceindex]
coldPath = volume:coldvolume/myniceindex/colddb

Option 2
As an alternative I can also mount to the subfolders on the NAS
by modifying /etc/fstab and letting the /mnt/coldvolume point to nfs://mynas/idx{01,02,03}

I can then distribute the volume definition to all 3 indexers like this
[volume:coldvolume]
path = /mnt/coldvolume/

Question: Is option 1 a valid / supported configuration for a Splunk indexer cluster?
Question: Or is option 2 the best practice?

Regards Rob van de Voort

Labels (1)
0 Karma
1 Solution

richgalloway
SplunkTrust
SplunkTrust

Option 1 is out because all indexers in a cluster must have the same config.

Option 2 is out because NFS is Not For Splunk (but may work if performance is up to spec).

---
If this reply helps you, Karma would be appreciated.

View solution in original post

rvdv
Explorer

Thank you for the quick response

0 Karma

richgalloway
SplunkTrust
SplunkTrust

Option 1 is out because all indexers in a cluster must have the same config.

Option 2 is out because NFS is Not For Splunk (but may work if performance is up to spec).

---
If this reply helps you, Karma would be appreciated.
Get Updates on the Splunk Community!

Splunk Enterprise Security 8.x: The Essential Upgrade for Threat Detection, ...

 Prepare to elevate your security operations with the powerful upgrade to Splunk Enterprise Security 8.x! This ...

Get Early Access to AI Playbook Authoring: Apply for the Alpha Private Preview ...

Passionate about security automation? Apply now to our AI Playbook Authoring Alpha private preview ...

Reduce and Transform Your Firewall Data with Splunk Data Management

Managing high-volume firewall data has always been a challenge. Noisy events and verbose traffic logs often ...