Splunk Search

sub search does not return string on splunk 8.1.4

kiyoshi_miyake
Explorer

I get number from subsearch but get null for string like below on splunk 8.1.4.
I found the splunk answer that resolved by appending "format", but it is not resolved for me. Is it bug on 8.x?

subsearch_issue.PNG

| makeresults
| eval foo = [ | makeresults | eval foo="123" | return $foo ]
| eval bar = [ | makeresults | eval bar="bar" | return $bar ]
| eval baz = tostring([ | makeresults | eval baz="baz" | return $baz ])
| eval qux = tostring([ | makeresults | eval qux="qux" | return $qux | format ])
| table _time foo bar baz qux

Labels (2)
0 Karma
1 Solution

ITWhisperer
SplunkTrust
SplunkTrust

If you expand the query (<ctrl><shift>E) you get this

| makeresults 
| eval foo = 123 
| eval bar = bar 
| eval baz = tostring( baz ) 
| eval qux = tostring( ( ( qux ) ) ) 
| table _time foo bar baz qux

Which explains all the null and empty fields

You can (almost) fix this by providing arguments to the format command - the result (if not numeric) still needs trimming

| makeresults
| eval foo = [ | makeresults | eval foo="123" | return $foo ]
| eval bar = trim([ | makeresults | eval bar="bar" | return $bar | format "\"" "" "" "" "" "\"" ])
| eval baz = tostring(trim([ | makeresults | eval baz="baz" | return $baz | format "\"" "" "" "" "" "\"" ]))
| eval qux = tostring(trim([ | makeresults | eval qux="qux" | return $qux | format "" "\"" "" "\"" "" "" ]))
| table _time foo bar baz qux

Giving

ITWhisperer_0-1643280109814.pngITWhisperer_1-1643280151197.png

 

View solution in original post

ITWhisperer
SplunkTrust
SplunkTrust

If you expand the query (<ctrl><shift>E) you get this

| makeresults 
| eval foo = 123 
| eval bar = bar 
| eval baz = tostring( baz ) 
| eval qux = tostring( ( ( qux ) ) ) 
| table _time foo bar baz qux

Which explains all the null and empty fields

You can (almost) fix this by providing arguments to the format command - the result (if not numeric) still needs trimming

| makeresults
| eval foo = [ | makeresults | eval foo="123" | return $foo ]
| eval bar = trim([ | makeresults | eval bar="bar" | return $bar | format "\"" "" "" "" "" "\"" ])
| eval baz = tostring(trim([ | makeresults | eval baz="baz" | return $baz | format "\"" "" "" "" "" "\"" ]))
| eval qux = tostring(trim([ | makeresults | eval qux="qux" | return $qux | format "" "\"" "" "\"" "" "" ]))
| table _time foo bar baz qux

Giving

ITWhisperer_0-1643280109814.pngITWhisperer_1-1643280151197.png

 

kiyoshi_miyake
Explorer

Wow! Thank you very much for quick and perfect answer! It works fine!

0 Karma
Get Updates on the Splunk Community!

Index This | What is broken 80% of the time by February?

December 2025 Edition   Hayyy Splunk Education Enthusiasts and the Eternally Curious!    We’re back with this ...

Unlock Faster Time-to-Value on Edge and Ingest Processor with New SPL2 Pipeline ...

Hello Splunk Community,   We're thrilled to share an exciting update that will help you manage your data more ...

Splunk MCP & Agentic AI: Machine Data Without Limits

Discover how the Splunk Model Context Protocol (MCP) Server can revolutionize the way your organization uses ...