Splunk Enterprise Security

Why ES threat list lookup fails on pivot data, but works with direct search on indexed data?

dragoslungu
Explorer

Is there anything different when running a lookup on data returned by a pivot compared to the same lookup running on data returned from a direct search on indexed data ?

The following lookup returns 1400 matches :

tag=ids tag=attack | lookup threatlist_lookup_by_str key AS dest
OUTPUTNEW name AS dest_threatlist_name| search dest_threatlist_name=*

If the same lookup runs agains a pivot, there are no matches:

| tstats `summariesonly` count from datamodel=Intrusion_Detection where
*  by _time,IDS_Attacks.src,IDS_Attacks.dest span=10m | `drop_dm_object_name("IDS_Attacks")` | lookup threatlist_lookup_by_str key AS dest OUTPUTNEW name AS dest_threatlist_name| search dest_threatlist_name=*

The root element definition of the Intrusion_Detection datamodel is the same as the direct search

tag=ids tag=attack

The purpose of this is to integrate custom threat lists in the default ES content like the "Threat List Activity" dashboard. Most of the ES default panels use datamodel / pivot searches which causes the lookups to fail.

Thanks.

sjohnson_splunk
Splunk Employee
Splunk Employee

Since your tstats is using summariesonly (which is true), it's possible that your data model accelerations are not keeping up and there are no results in the time window.

0 Karma
Get Updates on the Splunk Community!

Splunk APM & RUM | Upcoming Planned Maintenance

There will be planned maintenance of the streaming infrastructure for Splunk APM and Splunk RUM in the coming ...

Part 2: Diving Deeper With AIOps

Getting the Most Out of Event Correlation and Alert Storm Detection in Splunk IT Service Intelligence   Watch ...

User Groups | Upcoming Events!

If by chance you weren't already aware, the Splunk Community is host to numerous User Groups, organized ...