Change SSL Certificate port 8089 Breaks DUO Authentication

[bbbontrager]

I have changed the certificate on server.conf to take my created cert for port 8089. This is the same cert that I have been using for port 8000. I change server.conf according to documentation, reboot and verify the certificate. Port 8089 is pointing to the new cert. However, when trying to sign in to port 8000, I get the following error.

Login failed due to incorrectly configured Multifactor authentication. Contact Splunk support for resolving this issue

PLease advise, we are using DUO. 

This is what my sslConfig portion looks like in my server.conf

[sslConfig]
sslPassword = ******************************************************************************
privKeyPath = C:\Program Files\Splunk\etc\auth\mycerts\*****************.key
serverCert = C:\Program Files\Splunk\etc\auth\mycerts\*****************.pem
sslRootCAPath = C:\Program Files\Splunk\etc\auth\mycerts\************.pem
requireClientCert = False